PDA

View Full Version : United - Kansas Grades [R]


Pages : [1] 2 3 4

albionroad
13 May 2006, 11:11 PM
Perkins - 6.5
Erpen - 6
Boswell - 6
Namoff - 6
Carroll - 6
Mediate - 5.5
Adu - 7 (possibly the best game Freddy's ever played for United)
Gomez - 6.5
Gros - 6
Eskandarian - 7
Moreno - 5

Walker - N/R

Hedbal
13 May 2006, 11:19 PM
Perkins-6.5
Namoff -7
Boswell- 6
Erpen - 5.5
Mediate - 6
Adu - 6
Gomez - 6.5
Carroll - 6
Gros - 6
Eskandarian - 7
Moreno - 5.5

gnat
13 May 2006, 11:27 PM
Perkins - 6 - I think he was more lucky than good tonight, but hard to tell for sure. Did do some good stuff though.
Erpen - 4 - Is it me or is he getting scarier each week? If KC was any better they would have had a few goals off his gaffes.
Boswell - 5.5 - Steady for the most part, but a few WTF moments.
Namoff - 6 - Good to have him back. And he is still injured :eek:
Carroll - 6 - A nice solid performance.
Mediate - 6.5 - I was impressed with him. He was up and down the field, had a few nice crosses, and a nice shot that made Bo work.
Adu - N/R - I missed the Penalty so have no idea what happend. Otherwise he had an excellent game. It was great to see him use his teammates rather than always trying fancy foot work to get around defenders.
Gomez - 6.5 - He looked good out there.
Gros - 7 - He is just a monster going back and forth. Set up a few chances and blocked a few of KCs chances too.
Eskandarian - 7 - If he stays healthy, we might finally see the season we have always hoped for.
Moreno - 6 - He best game this season. He seemed to be much more on his game and didn't appear worn out by the 60th.

Walker - 6 - This is how he should always be used. Had a great shot there at the end too.

Bo was the MOTM for KC. Moreno, Adu, and Walker all would have had goals too if he wasn't the beast that he was.

-dave

Mountainia
13 May 2006, 11:28 PM
Perkins-6 Some good saves, one real lucky miss
Namoff -5 some offense from his side.
Boswell-6 Seems solid in the middle
Erpen - 5 scares the heck out of me
Mediate - 5 Who? Saw some decent stuff
Adu - 6 He is learning a more complete game
Gomez - 7 I thought Gomez was on tonight
Carroll - 6 stiched together a shaky back tonight
Gros - 6 All over the place
Eskandarian - 7 Killer shot
Moreno - 5 Can hold the ball, but can't seem to get by anymore
Walker - NR But was doing well in his two minutes

Seem kind of high scores considering we hardly had the ball all night. Oh well.

Sundevil9
13 May 2006, 11:38 PM
Perkins-5.5
Namoff -5
Boswell-5.5
Erpen - 5.5
Mediate - 5.5
Adu - 4.5
Gomez - 6.5
Carroll - 5.5
Gros - 6
Eskandarian - 6.5
Moreno - 5.5
Walker - NR

VLADYD
14 May 2006, 12:00 AM
Perkins - 5.5 Good saves but his distribution with his feet was awful, Consistently gave balls away
Erpen - 6 Solid game cleaned up a lot of midfiled mistakes
Boswell - 6 Solid game cleaned up a lot of midfield mistakes
Namoff - 6 Good first game back, very active
Carroll - 4.5 Gave away a lot of balls
Mediate - 6.5 great game until he tired in the second half.
Adu - 3 This guy should not be starting. Gave away a penalty and jogged the rest of the game. Missed a sitter from Moreno. Frankly, I'm dissapointed in his play and I want to see him succeed. He should have been subbed.
Gomez - 7 Man of the match
Gros - 6 Solid game, cleaned up a lot of midfield mistakes
Eskandarian - 6 Still needs to stop holding his head after misses. Make the effing shot. Well taken goal
Moreno - 7 Co-man of the match. If Freddy and Jamal could finish we would win 4-1.

Walker - 5 Should have finished the chance he had

MattMathai
14 May 2006, 12:01 AM
Seem kind of high scores considering we hardly had the ball all night. Oh well.

Scores always tend to be high, but 'hardly had the ball all night'???

Th4119
14 May 2006, 12:11 AM
Perkins - 5.5 - Lots of rebounds, very sloppy distribution. Good on crosses.
Namoff - 5 - Nothing spectacular, nothing horrible.
Boswell - 5 - Needs to watch the fouls around the box.
Erpen - 5.5 - Decent.
Mediate - 6.5 - Came out of nowhere and played very well. Very impressed with his work coming off of the reserve squad.
Adu - 6.5 - Very good, finishing needs some improvement.
Gomez - 7.5 - Brilliant at times. Set up both goals plus numerous other chances and contributed on defense.
Carroll - 5.5 - Messed up on the play that led to KC's PK. Solid overall, but not the form we've seen the last few weeks.
Gros - 5 - Great match except for repeated pathetic crosses. Talk about a chronic trend.
Eskandarian - 6.5 - Stellar goal, solid match overall.
Moreno - 6.5 - Much more active than he's been lately. Good to see him more involved.

Nowak - 5 - Got Moreno back towards normal, but put in Jamil 15 minutes too late. The last half hour of the game had Walker written all over it and he should've been there sooner.

giffenbone
14 May 2006, 12:27 AM
Perkins - 6
Erpen - 5.5
Boswell - 5.5
Namoff - 6
Carroll - 5.5
Mediate - 6
Adu - 6.5
Gomez - 6
Gros - 6.5
Eskandarian - 7
Moreno - 5

Walker - 6 (would be N/R but once he came in it was game over...he's a spark late).

DaPrince84
14 May 2006, 01:18 AM
Perkins- 5.5... made good saves, but didnt distribute that well... looked shaky
Erpen- 3.5... was the worst player on the field for United... did stupid stuff
Boswell- 5.5... solid game
Namoff- 6... very impressive... nice run in the 2nd half
Carroll- 5.5... solid
Mediate- 6.5... great runs... should scored on his 2nd chance... but was dangerous
Adu-7... Should have had 2 goals in all honesty... but he is learning... and even tho he got a penalty (he hardly touched the guy)... the fact that he ran back was something he is learning
Gomez-7... dominated when DC had possession
Gros- 6... was all over the field...
Eskie-6... a superb goal... and looked dangerous... attacked...
Moreno 5.5- Got a goal of a PK, but he looks slow...
Walker- 5... he is all wheels... but annoys me because he shows no other skill... had a good chance but placed it to the keeper

I was impressed by Mediate

ursula
14 May 2006, 03:00 AM
Perkins - 6.5 Hopefully Nicky was taking notes on how to handle crosses.
Erpen - 6 A bit uneven because he had much to do.
Boswell - 5 Quiet and could well have been sent off for his foul on Sealy.
Namoff - 6 Very busy. I like him more as a defender
Carroll - 6 Good game but needed more support in the midfield
Mediate - 5.5 Not bad for a debut
Adu - 6 Not enough defense
Gomez - 6.5 See Adu
Gros - 6.5 Wonderful to see a player blossom before your eyes.
Eskandarian - 7 Guy knows first time volleys.
Moreno - 5 I don't know if he got tired as he did some nice running at the defense in the end. If not then he failed to deliver defensive pressure.

Walker - 6 Energised the offense.

griffin1108
14 May 2006, 09:09 AM
Perkins - 6 was tested often and measured up
Erpen - 5.5 great skills, had his brain fart with the weak back pass to Perkins
Boswell - 5.5 very steady, but little in offense
Namoff - 6 made some useful overlaps, much better in back that in midfield
Carroll - 6.5 played like there was two of him (which was necessary because he got little help)
Mediate - 5 no pace, torched by Arnaud in first half, settled down in second
Adu - 5 he shouldn't be asked to play Ben's role - he can't
Gomez - 6 clearly winded at the end, but great ball winning on 50/50's earlier
Gros - 6 he is and will be a beast
Eskandarian - 6.5 not often you get a real-time replay of an earlier season goal
Moreno - 5.5 more energy, needs to work more on defense

Walker - 5.5 showed great composure by walking the ball to the corner to kill time, should have done better with his chance, but was unlucky Bo caught the rebound

Nowak - 5 gets away with Mediate start, Piotr you can use 3 subs.

NattyBo
14 May 2006, 09:16 AM
Adu misses 2 sitters, gives away a penalty and plays sketchy defense all night, yet, people are consistantly rating him higher than Moreno.

Huh.

VLADYD
14 May 2006, 10:48 AM
Adu misses 2 sitters, gives away a penalty and plays sketchy defense all night, yet, people are consistantly rating him higher than Moreno.

Huh.

Hey, he was lucky to get a 3 from me. People give Moreno a poor rating, however, had The Kitten and Jamil converted their chances, Jamie would be sitting on a goal and 2 primary assist game.

CHICO13
14 May 2006, 10:52 AM
People give Moreno a poor rating, however, had The Kitten and Jamil converted their chances, Jamie would be sitting on a goal and 2 primary assist game.
That's because people have made their minds up about Jaime.

Mountainia
14 May 2006, 11:52 AM
Scores always tend to be high, but 'hardly had the ball all night'???
Well, for us.

Primate
14 May 2006, 12:13 PM
Perkins - 5.5 Good saves but his distribution with his feet was awful, Consistently gave balls away
Erpen - 6 Solid game cleaned up a lot of midfiled mistakes
Boswell - 6 Solid game cleaned up a lot of midfield mistakes
Namoff - 6 Good first game back, very active
Carroll - 4.5 Gave away a lot of balls
Mediate - 6.5 great game until he tired in the second half.
Adu - 3 This guy should not be starting. Gave away a penalty and jogged the rest of the game. Missed a sitter from Moreno. Frankly, I'm dissapointed in his play and I want to see him succeed. He should have been subbed.
Gomez - 7 Man of the match
Gros - 6 Solid game, cleaned up a lot of midfield mistakes
Eskandarian - 6 Still needs to stop holding his head after misses. Make the effing shot. Well taken goal
Moreno - 7 Co-man of the match. If Freddy and Jamal could finish we would win 4-1.

Walker - 5 Should have finished the chance he had

I really don't see Jaime getting the same rating or even close as Gomez. Your criticism of Adu could easily be applied to Jaime as well.
That penalty was very soft and at least he was back for that play. He wouldn't have had to be if Carrol didn't screw up.
I think you're a little harsh on Eskandarian as well. If you're going to be easy on Moreno because he's a "forward" and only need to play hard 10 minutes a game you should apply the same to Eskandarian.

Perkins - 5.5 He seemed to react a little slow to many plays and his distribution was off most of the time but he still had a couple of good saves.
Erpen - 4.5 I think he's getting worse as the season goes on.
Boswell - 5.5 He did pretty well, but got beat a couple times too.
Namoff - 6.5 Good to have him back, after a shaky start he picked it up and made a couple of good runs forward.
Carroll - 5 He had a pretty shaky game but he wasn't that bad.
Mediate - 6.5 I liked him a lot.He made some good runs and it's unfortunate DC didn't use his side of the field more often.
Adu - 5 Played a position that isn't his strong suit, had a couple of chances but didn't go at anyone when I think he should have.
Gomez - 7 Nice game, he tired at the end though.
Gros - 6.5 Love to watch this guy run. He still needs to work on his crosses.
Eskandarian - 7 Great game
Moreno - 4.5 A little better than last game.I would love to see him run every once in awhile. He always seems like he's saving his energy for one run a game. He had some smart passes but also had several times where he held the ball way too long.

Walker - n/r Great late game sub, I think we should see him at the end of every game we want to press the oppositions defense.

Primate
14 May 2006, 12:20 PM
Adu misses 2 sitters, gives away a penalty and plays sketchy defense all night, yet, people are consistantly rating him higher than Moreno.

Huh.
I don't know that I'd call them sitters but they were definately good chances.
At least he's getting them, what did Moreno do to warrant a good score?

bigredfutbol
14 May 2006, 12:37 PM
That's because people have made their minds up about Jaime.

Which is ridiculous considering we're only a few games into a long season. He played well last night.

pokemoncards
14 May 2006, 12:41 PM
I don't know that I'd call them sitters but they were definately good chances.
At least he's getting them, what did Moreno do to warrant a good score?

set up those good chances