Should Paolo Guerrero stay or go?

[KesOne]

BTW Congratulations Bayern!!!
I started this thread because I have a concern for Guerrero. The guy is just not getting played. Ever since RSC came back, at least from my observations, Magath plays him less and less. And yes him being from Peru and knowing his potential is why I'm concerned.

[meista.de]

I would say let him go, if they sign podolski Guerrero will get even less playing time.

[Bayerntone]

Paolo has been the super-sub from the bench. His presence was intrumental in quite a no. of matches.

However, I can see no future in him at Bayern. Go to some other clubs in the BuLi so that I could still monitor his play please. I say that for his own good, in the long run!

[Guti™]

Sell him to a smaller club, I say. He is good enough to start in most BL teams but I wouldnt mind a move to a better league like La Liga.

[ROMERO879]

Sell him to a smaller club, I say. He is good enough to start in most BL teams but I wouldnt mind a move to a better league like La Liga.
ouch :p

sell him ;)

[Duncan Idaho]

the answer to this question depends on the transfers for the next season and it can't be answered at the moment cause there are too many transfer rumors around

[BMike86]

I think he should go to a top flight Bundesliga club, i dont know where, but sort of like similar situation with Valdez probably moving from Bremen to Dortmund. I would like to see him probably with a club like Stuttgart or some club like that. Where they are a pretty good club but only need a player or two to shoot them into that contender role.

[snoooop]

the most smaller Bundesliga clubs dont want him, because he is known as a very unfair player, a diver and a player who spit at other players.

so i dont think there are many clubs interested in him. ;) he is an average player for an club like Bayern, a perfect one for the bench, all big clubs need such players for the bench, but i dont see there a chance to start. and now has start the german youth-academys producing a lot of german talents (it was about time :) ), wich come up in 2-3 years and then is there 0,0 chance for him anymore.

[KesOne]

the most smaller Bundesliga clubs dont want him, because he is known as a very unfair player, a diver and a player who spit at other players.

so i dont think there are many clubs interested in him. ;) he is an average player for an club like Bayern, a perfect one for the bench, all big clubs need such players for the bench, but i dont see there a chance to start. and now has start the german youth-academys producing a lot of german talents (it was about time :) ), wich come up in 2-3 years and then is there 0,0 chance for him anymore.

While I'll respect your opinion. I also feel he should go on one hand and on the other, he could really pay his dues and eventually be the replacement for Makaay and/or Pizarro. As long as he keeps scoring and impressing the Bayern Club he still has a chance. Does he have the patience? We shall see.

[snoooop]

While I'll respect your opinion. I also feel he should go on one hand and on the other, he could really pay his dues and eventually be the replacement for Makaay and/or Pizarro. As long as he keeps scoring and impressing the Bayern Club he still has a chance. Does he have the patience? We shall see.


i think sometimes the people misunderstand me here. i have nothing against peru, nothing against guererro and nothing against Pizarro.
i was very happy when Pizza joined Bayern and i still see there the talent of Guererro, but a Player like Trochowski was here just the Kid from the own youth with a lot of talent(like Guererro), he joined Hamburg and is there now starter and doing it very good. so Guererro should join another club or he will sit the next 10 years on Bayern bench. or Frings was doing it in Munich not that good, he is now Captain at Bremen and one of the most important players.

and i always say, when you can have an average german or european player, buy him and dont buy an average southamerican, thats not because i hate them, its because a player from germany, france or holland, has approximately the same mentality, feels more at home here and dont need so much time to fit in the european and german style of football.

Ze Roberto is starter at brazilian nationalteam and is sitting the half time on bayerns bench, you know?
look at Alou Diarra he was playing in Bayern Youth/Amateur teams and today he is French International, sometimes is a club-chance very good for a player, especially for young ones.

but it has nothing to do with racism or hate. we all love the southeramerican way of playing football, their skills and technics.

[ForeverRed]

Bayern should not sell him but loan him out to another team, preferably outside of Germany, let him get a feel for the game for a year or two and see if he comes back as the full 100% finished product.

[SirManchester]

I fully agree with this ^

[essie_majedi]

did the same thing they did to Philip Lahm

[mofo4life]

agreed, loan him out. Next year he would be only foward Nr. 5

[BMike86]

if we have Santa Cruz, Pizarro, Makaay and Podolski I think we will be fine. So loaning him out could only help, and if he likes it where he is or the club wants him then maybe we can get some money out of him. It could all work out really nicely, im sure there are several clubs that would take advantage of his services, even in spain! but i would be hoping he'd stick around in the bundesliga for a top flight club

[pizarro_boy]

he should go (may be on loan)

[Dead Fingers]

I would like to loan him to a weaker squad. He is young and needs a bit more playing time.
However, Santa Cruz is never consistently healthy, so again ..it all depends on what the transfer market brings in.

[Bayerntone]

Santa Cruz has given an outstanding performance against Stuttgart.

Why should people be so intorlerant to a good performer as to the point of getting rid of him?

Has he done anything noticeably disastrous in the match against Lautern?

[Dead Fingers]

Santa Cruz has given an outstanding performance against Stuttgart.

Why should people be so intorlerant to a good performer as to the point of getting rid of him?

Has he done anything noticeably disastrous in the match against Lautern?

Who said I was intolerant of SC???:confused:
I was just talking about his fitness. Fact: he is injury prone.

[Bayerntone]

I would like to loan him to a weaker squad. He is young and needs a bit more playing time.
However, Santa Cruz is never consistently healthy, so again ..it all depends on what the transfer market brings in.

The highlighted wordings ... if that was not really what you meant, thats fine then.