PDA

View Full Version : Chances not Fancied: How these young players failed to help the US at the World Cup


Pages : [1] 2 3 4

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 06:39 PM
]THE ROAD TO GERMANY
PLAYERS NOT FANCING THEIR CHANCES

http://www.covers.com/images/2006/180x180/buddle_edson060407.jpghttp://www.getakickoutofreading.org/images/2005/coloring/CLB_martino_thumb.jpg
Former teammates Kyle Martino and Edson Buddle could have been stars for the United States this World Cup. Instead, they will be in MLS thinking about why they didn’t make the final roster, says Andrew Jerell Jones.

Jonathan Spector was hell bent on forcing Bruce Arena’s hand like a good card player at the World Series of Poker does at trapping one of his opponents with a shrewd bluff.

With a series of consistent and exciting performances for Charlton Athletic in the capricious and undeniable quality of the Barclays’ English Premier League, the on loan Manchester United left back seemed to be a young man that just could not be left off the final 23 man roster for the United States World Cup campaign this summer. His amalgamation of pace, ball skill, positioning, and precociousness seemed to make him a better choice for being an eighth defender than both Greg Berhaulter and Chris Albright, because it would be hard to dismiss Frankie Hedjuk off the roster with his mix of experience and workrate from four years ago.

However, just as things seemed to be brightening in the summer horizon for the 20 year old, Spector suffered a frightening injury on Tuesday night against Portsmouth. And with a dislocating shoulder ending his Premiership excursion this year that has included noteworthy performances for both the Sir Alex Ferguson and unheralded London club, it signaled a permanent end to his World Cup bid (and misses up FIFA’s Best Young Player at this World Cup for the USA since the other selection, Freddy Adu, will most likely not be on the roster) for this go around.

While Spector tried his ultimate best to be one of the men announced on May 2 by the incumbent manager, there are other players of supreme talent in the US player pool who have failed at following in the footsteps of Landon Donovan and DaMarcus Beasley as young players making huge impacts on Soccer’s grandest stage.

For every Clint Dempsey, Oguchi Onewyu, Eddie Johnson, and Bobby Convey who have stepped up to the occasion and lived up to their hype enough to be locks this summer for Germany over the four year cycle, there have been a plethora of others who haven’t harnessed their physical abilities with any mental consistently.

Arguably the position that the United States has failed to add depth to has been the playmaking midfield position, where arguably the hybrid forward Landon Donovan and a returning from injury John O’Brien are the only two capable players. While the States made their improbable run in that summer adventure in Korea/Japan four years ago, a former University of Virginia lad was drawing praise for his rookie campaign with the Columbus Crew back in MLS. Kyle Martino was receiving strong accoldates from the likes of Georgi Cicunalia and many others as a possible number 10 for the United States for many years to come. That sentiment was shared by the likes of Eric Wynalda, John Harks, and many other soccer analysis in the country, as Martino validated his potential at being a future creative wizard for his country by claiming the Rookie of the Year Award in the American domestic league in the same year and following it up with an impressive performance at the 2003 FIFA Confederations Cup.

But after suffering hard tackle after hard tackle in the last game of that same international competition against Cameroon, Martino has never really been the same player. With constant role changes under former Crew coach Greg Andrulis and basic poor play, the Wesport, Connecticut native was never consistent enough to be apart of any significant games for the US in qualifying for this upcoming international battle of soccer supremacy. It seemed that Martino had one last gasp opportunity to make the squad thanks to the lack of depth in that position magnetized by the inactivity of O’Brien. After a strong end to the disastrous season the Crew endured, Martino was given the start by Arena in the America’s last qualifier against Panama, tapping off a resurgent final part of his utterwise disappointing 2005 with his first international goal off a well timed volley in the US 2-0 victory. Like Taylor Twellman, who also scored his first goal for his country on the senior level in that match, it seemed that goal would propel Martino into playing to his ability and being a factor for the team. But after a decent but unspectacular run in the MLS National Team training camp held in January by Arena, Martino has wallowed back into mediocrity and has put his position on the team in the future in some doubt.

Though uncertainty over his National Team future isn’t in question like the Columbus midfielder, Martino’s new teammate Eddie Gaven also didn’t cash in on his 2006 World Cup prospects. If you had anyone taking bets about the possible 23 man roster come Germany time in 2004, most would have placed their money on the security blanket that was Gaven at that point. At the tender age of 17, he was outstanding for the team then known as the New York Metrostars by making MLS’s best 11 with his precocious play in the midfield. He and Amando Guevara formed a dangerous duo in the heart of the pitch that year, and Gaven was rewarded with his first ever cap against Poland in Chicago.

http://www.mlsnet.com/images/2005/08/17/AbuV5hWN.jpg
[FONT="Arial Black"]Justin Mapp has terrific talent, but he failed to caress it enough to be a revelation at this summer’s World Cup

However, after a torrid start to the 2005 season with the team now known as the New York Red Bulls, Gaven’s quality declined after disappointing efforts at the Under 20 World Championships last year in Holland, where he, Spector and Freddy Adu were outshined by less heralded players on the US roster at that tournament . His play collapsed to a point where not only he fell off the radar of the National Team picture, but also led to his value for the metropolitan outlet diminishing rapidly. Through never acclaimed for his defensive capabilities, there were times last year where Gaven didn’t hustle on the other end like he should have, and that is a huge proponent for Arena and his expectations for his midfielders. With Gaven’s inability to know if he was a two way midfielder , a playmaker behind the forwards, or a withdrawl forward and his lost of confidence over the course of last season, New York/New Jersey traded away the once untouchable player despite scoring 8 goals at the grizzled age of 18 to Columbus. His swamp for Edson Buddle fully displayed the disappointment the former clubs of both players expressed over them.

For Buddle, the physical gifts he has been given as a soccer player are something not even most world class players possess. Amply named after the middle title of the great Pele’, the stout forward has an arsenal in his aptitude that arguably no American forward has ever had: speed, strength, dribbling, free kick ability, and finishing. For years since he joined the Crew in 2001, Buddle has shown that array of talent that has made many pencil him in as a definitive part of the United States becoming an international soccer power. This was maximized further with his brilliant four goal performance against the Metrostars in September 2004, showing that he was ready to be a consistent presence on the national team squad after receiving one cap to his name back in 2003. However, injuries and a lack of effort reared its ugly head into the soccer life of the former youth international forward last year, as Buddle only scored 9 goals and was occasionally either subbed off early or wasn’t included in the starting 11. Add an arrest for DUI over that course of time and it lead to the worst year of Buddle’s career and sealing his fate of going to Germany this summer.

Though not involve in any trade talks because of his unique qualities that make him a rare commodity in this league, Justin Mapp has also missed out of his chances at being apart of possible World Cup glory this summer. When on his game, the Brandon, Mississippi native is a light version of Arjen Robben, a pure dynamic winger whose ability to dribble up the flanks and increase his speed on the ball is what makes him a special player in the America soccer world. After showing the flashes of brilliance in his debut years of 2003 and 2004, an easy jump into MLS Best X1 and a solid place on the national team for years to come was expected of Mapp in 2005. However, the former Under 20 star continued to do what he did the first two years, show flashes of brilliance and maddening inconsistency. For most MLS flank midfielders, three goals and eight assists would not be something that brings total disappointment to your resume, especially if they were both career highs, which was the case for the Fire #21. But for Mapp, that was the case, as he still struggled to maintain full 90 minute dominance on his side of the field due in part to his non existent defensive efforts. He was given one last lifeline for Germany by Arena with an invitation to the January MLS training camp, but an injury diminished all hope for many fans of this stylish and exciting talent.

Though not as obvious or close to being a mainstay on the national team as those mentioned above, there are many other young players who didn’t use their apparent ability to be on the final 23 man roster. Santino Quarenta of DC United, who came out of shape to Arena’s training camp in January, former Real Salt Lake goalkeeper D.J. Countless, Danny Scetala of the Crew, Kyle Beckerman of the Rapids, Ricardo Clark (though unfortunately injured for training camp as well) and Brad Davis of the Houston Dynamos, Chris Gbandi (no longer with the potential of playing for America with his decision to play for his country of birth, Liberia) of FC Dallas, and Memo Gonzalez of the Galaxy, who has been on the field less than Darko Milicic had been on the court for the Detroit Pistons. Jose Burciaga Jr of the Wizards, Nate Jaqua of the Fire, and Alecko Eskandrian of DC United have faced multiple injuries, and it would be harsh to criticize them for wasting their talents because of ailing limbs. However, all of these players were all touted as major players for the United States Senior National Team, and still maybe in the future.

However, the future will not be on June 12, 2006 when the States will play the Czech Republic in the first match. A match that will have lots of young players back in many parts of America wishing that they harnessed their abilities and combine it with mental bravado like Donovan and Beasley did four years ago.

Surely Spector was trying to do just that.

subbuteo
24 Apr 2006, 07:05 PM
I have a question: did you copy this from somewhere? If so, can you include the link back to the original aritcle so the site/author gets credit?

And if this is your own, really, really long post: How do you find the time?

thepundit
24 Apr 2006, 07:15 PM
Arguably the position that the United States has failed to add depth to has been the playmaking midfield position, where arguably the hybrid forward Landon Donovan and a returning from injury John O’Brien are the only two capable players.

and Convey, Wolff, and Dempsey......

i agree with almost everything you say there but man why hasn't anyone said anything about Jeff Cunningham? he scores all kinds of goals and has so many qualities that our forwards lack! did you see him against Real Madrid for the crap MLS Select team? dude was unstoppable!

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 07:22 PM
I have a question: did you copy this from somewhere? If so, can you include the link back to the original aritcle so the site/author gets credit?

And if this is your own, really, really long post: How do you find the time?

Nah, this is my column, no links, no website, just my column

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 07:24 PM
and Convey, Wolff, and Dempsey......

i agree with almost everything you say there but man why hasn't anyone said anything about Jeff Cunningham? he scores all kinds of goals and has so many qualities that our forwards lack! did you see him against Real Madrid for the crap MLS Select team? dude was unstoppable!

Jeff Cunningham just isn't a young player who the US hyped in the last four years compared to any of the others

Convey and Dempsey aren't playing making midfielders like Ronaldino or Riquelme, or Totti or Pirlo per se. And Wolff hasn't played that position, although i think he wouldn't be that bad as far as I am concerned.

kinstlinger
24 Apr 2006, 07:25 PM
The opinions of Wynalda and Harkes don't mean that much.. pundits annoint every young player to be the next this and that.. just that we've got so few in the 'senior' soccer ranks, that the few that exist tend to seem more prevalent.

I remember loving the idea of Martino.. seemed to be the natural successor to Reyna as m/f captain, but didn't work out like that. If the guy has the goods, he'll show them.. doesn't really matter his coaching situation, IMHO.

One of the things we'll have to accept as a developing soccer country is that each guy in MLS who shows promise doesn't get a bye onto the national side.. this isn't like '90-'97, where each guy with a great-grand relative from the US was scouted.. and that's a good thing.

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 07:29 PM
The opinions of Wynalda and Harkes don't mean that much.. pundits annoint every young player to be the next this and that.. just that we've got so few in the 'senior' soccer ranks, that the few that exist tend to seem more prevalent.

I remember loving the idea of Martino.. seemed to be the natural successor to Reyna as m/f captain, but didn't work out like that. If the guy has the goods, he'll show them.. doesn't really matter his coaching situation, IMHO.

One of the things we'll have to accept as a developing soccer country is that each guy in MLS who shows promise doesn't get a bye onto the national side.. this isn't like '90-'97, where each guy with a great-grand relative from the US was scouted.. and that's a good thing.

I agree with you, but only if those guys truely aren't good enough like Martino proved in his first two seasons of MLS that he could fit that role, unlike say a Devin Barclay or a Jamar Beasley who didn't prove a single thing in MLS really. If guys display their talent at least inconsistently, then if they are focused and dedicated to being the best they can, they could easily be on the national team roster.

dmike
24 Apr 2006, 07:34 PM
I wish Edson would of gotten another chance.. he looks like a healthier EJ right now

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 07:41 PM
I wish Edson would of gotten another chance.. he looks like a healthier EJ right now

Yeha, but he wasn't good on Saturday himself. And Johnson is healthy, just not dominating the league.

Lord15
24 Apr 2006, 07:43 PM
People may not like, but the column is pretty accurate.

A LOT of missed opportunity in the last 2 years.

Stogey23
24 Apr 2006, 08:01 PM
Someone needs to send Justin Mapp a tape of Aaron Lennon's game against Arsenal.

Flick On
24 Apr 2006, 08:15 PM
For every Clint Dempsey, Oguchi Onewyu, Eddie Johnson, and Bobby Convey who have stepped up to the occasion and lived up to their hype enough to be locks this summer for Germany over the four year cycle, there have been a plethora of others who haven’t harnessed their physical abilities with any mental consistently.

So you want a reply? Here it is:

What exactly does mental consistently mean?

[/QUOTE] With constant role changes under former Crew coach Greg Andrulis and basic poor play, the Wesport, Connecticut native was never consistent enough to be apart of any significant games for the US in qualifying for this upcoming international battle of soccer supremacy. [/QUOTE]

Perhaps lousy coaching and consant role changes is one of the main reason Martino has not shined on a consisent basis. If Martino had played consistently in his natural position on a better team, maybe things would be different. Do you think that lousy coaching is a possible reason that Martino has not reached his potential, or do you simply blame the player?

[/QUOTE] With Gaven’s inability to know if he was a two way midfielder, a playmaker behind the forwards, or a withdrawl forward and his lost of confidence over the course of last season, New York/New Jersey traded away the once untouchable player despite scoring 8 goals at the grizzled age of 18 to Columbus. [/QUOTE]

Ditto for Gaven. When Gaven had his best season in 2004, he was playing centrally with Guevara in a box midfield with more freedom to attack. During 2005, he was playing mainly on the flank, with much less freedom. In any case, 8 goals and 4 assists is a pretty good year from a 19-year old playing right midfield. As with Martino, if Gaven was playing more in his more natural position, things may have worked out different.

[/QUOTE] However, the former Under 20 star continued to do what he did the first two years, show flashes of brilliance and maddening inconsistency. For most MLS flank midfielders, three goals and eight assists would not be something that brings total disappointment to your resume, especially if they were both career highs, which was the case for the Fire #21. But for Mapp, that was the case, as he still struggled to maintain full 90 minute dominance on his side of the field due in part to his non existent defensive efforts. [/QUOTE]

Maintain full 90-minute dominance and non-existing defensive efforts? Exaggerate much?

[/QUOTE] However, the future will not be on June 12, 2006 when the States will play the Czech Republic in the first match. A match that will have lots of young players back in many parts of America wishing that they harnessed their abilities and combine it with mental bravado like Donovan and Beasley did four years ago. [/QUOTE]

What exactly does mental bravado mean? You also fail to note that Donovan and Beasley had less competition for spots than the players you are trying to marginalize in your post. Another thing you fail to consider in your complicated and exaggerated analysis.

thepundit
24 Apr 2006, 08:50 PM
Convey and Dempsey aren't playing making midfielders like Ronaldino or Riquelme, or Totti or Pirlo per se. And Wolff hasn't played that position, although i think he wouldn't be that bad as far as I am concerned.

Convey does really well for Reading at CAM when he plays there. we don't have a single player that plays like Riquelme or Ronaldinho. i wouldn't classify Ronaldinho as a midfielder, anyway. in Riquelme's case: there is nobody even remotely like him. he goes everywhre on the field to get the ball and isnt' the out and out attacking midfielder that we're talking about. he simply operates the entire team that he plays on.

i'm sorry bed-sty but it seems like you're trying to be like a pro columnist rather than a poster and you have a lot of text in the post while saying very little.

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 09:50 PM
Convey does really well for Reading at CAM when he plays there. we don't have a single player that plays like Riquelme or Ronaldinho. i wouldn't classify Ronaldinho as a midfielder, anyway. in Riquelme's case: there is nobody even remotely like him. he goes everywhre on the field to get the ball and isnt' the out and out attacking midfielder that we're talking about. he simply operates the entire team that he plays on.

i'm sorry bed-sty but it seems like you're trying to be like a pro columnist rather than a poster and you have a lot of text in the post while saying very little.

How am I saying little? I am showing the many players who miseed out on their chances to show that opportunity to play on the World Cup, and I have yet to see Convey play strictly in the middle for Reading. Yes, he comes to the middle occasionally, but he isn't the playmaker in the middle of the park all the time. He is a winger and if he were a playmaker, then he would be the ideal number 10 on the Nats team.

You don't have to be of Ronaldino's talent to play that position. Peter Nowak played it, Andy Herzog played it, and they aren't spectacular talents, but good players.

jbeall
24 Apr 2006, 09:54 PM
]
[CENTER]http://www.mlsnet.com/images/2005/08/17/AbuV5hWN.jpg
Justin Mapp has terrific talent, but he failed to caress it enough to be a revelation at this summer’s World Cup


Isn't 'caressing your talent' another euphemism for masturbation? :D


Great post, btw. Rep forthcoming.

forza inter
24 Apr 2006, 10:02 PM
unlike most everyone else, im gonna thank you for the post. i enjoyed reading it alot. good to see a summed up and compiled look at all the guys who could have been for this cycle. im not gonna rip ya man, i appreciate the offering.



forza inter

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 10:04 PM
So you want a reply? Here it is:

What exactly does mental consistently mean?

With constant role changes under former Crew coach Greg Andrulis and basic poor play, the Wesport, Connecticut native was never consistent enough to be apart of any significant games for the US in qualifying for this upcoming international battle of soccer supremacy. [/QUOTE]

Perhaps lousy coaching and consant role changes is one of the main reason Martino has not shined on a consisent basis. If Martino had played consistently in his natural position on a better team, maybe things would be different. Do you think that lousy coaching is a possible reason that Martino has not reached his potential, or do you simply blame the player?

[/QUOTE] With Gaven’s inability to know if he was a two way midfielder, a playmaker behind the forwards, or a withdrawl forward and his lost of confidence over the course of last season, New York/New Jersey traded away the once untouchable player despite scoring 8 goals at the grizzled age of 18 to Columbus. [/QUOTE]

Ditto for Gaven. When Gaven had his best season in 2004, he was playing centrally with Guevara in a box midfield with more freedom to attack. During 2005, he was playing mainly on the flank, with much less freedom. In any case, 8 goals and 4 assists is a pretty good year from a 19-year old playing right midfield. As with Martino, if Gaven was playing more in his more natural position, things may have worked out different.

[/QUOTE] However, the former Under 20 star continued to do what he did the first two years, show flashes of brilliance and maddening inconsistency. For most MLS flank midfielders, three goals and eight assists would not be something that brings total disappointment to your resume, especially if they were both career highs, which was the case for the Fire #21. But for Mapp, that was the case, as he still struggled to maintain full 90 minute dominance on his side of the field due in part to his non existent defensive efforts. [/QUOTE]

Maintain full 90-minute dominance and non-existing defensive efforts? Exaggerate much?

[/QUOTE] However, the future will not be on June 12, 2006 when the States will play the Czech Republic in the first match. A match that will have lots of young players back in many parts of America wishing that they harnessed their abilities and combine it with mental bravado like Donovan and Beasley did four years ago. [/QUOTE]

What exactly does mental bravado mean? You also fail to note that Donovan and Beasley had less competition for spots than the players you are trying to marginalize in your post. Another thing you fail to consider in your complicated and exaggerated analysis.[/QUOTE]

Bravado- (Noun) boldness intended to impress or humiliate

You have to realize through, Donovan and certainly not Beasley would not be on the team if Arena didn't think they were ready, so don't discredit their performance, they were special for US standards because they stayed consistent and made the most of their opportunities, especially Beasley, who had to prove it over a shorter period of time (basically 8 or 9 months with the Nats before the Cup) compared to Martino, Gaven, Mapp, Buddle and the others (2 or more years).

All of these players in this thread I mentioned should take responsibility for not being on the team or playing to their best to be on the team. Coaching could have help in that failure to play to potential, but they need to look at themselves.

And you basically said what i said in the article with Martino, though I never said "lousy coaching" with Andrulis (even if I may have implied it) .

How is it exaggerated, Gaven doesn't play defense that well, Mapp certainly doens't play defense that well, it is the truth. For a person of his abilities, Mapp should be dominating week in and week out instead of getting subbed off like he did at times last year.

Gaven is still being juggled between forward or right midfielder or anything elsae that has to deal with an offensive position.

There's nothing ridiculously exaggerated at all my friend, but that's your opinion.

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 10:05 PM
Isn't 'caressing your talent' another euphemism for masturbation? :D


Great post, btw. Rep forthcoming.

LOL, man, I'm not even going there, thanks.

giffenbone
24 Apr 2006, 10:05 PM
Convey does really well for Reading at CAM when he plays there. we don't have a single player that plays like Riquelme or Ronaldinho. i wouldn't classify Ronaldinho as a midfielder, anyway. in Riquelme's case: there is nobody even remotely like him. he goes everywhre on the field to get the ball and isnt' the out and out attacking midfielder that we're talking about. he simply operates the entire team that he plays on.

i'm sorry bed-sty but it seems like you're trying to be like a pro columnist rather than a poster and you have a lot of text in the post while saying very little.


No offense, but i agree with thepundit. If you want to write columns, start your own website (like this whole "my best game" series...yawn). In all blunt honesty it is average stuff, but I do commend you for at putting in effort. And yes there is a lot of text while saying little. Like that blurb about the World Series of Poker which wasn't needed...yawn. And that's just one example. Before you rip me for saying this, just note that whatever you post is subject to be ripped especially if it is an attempt at an article/column. Anybody who writes columns receives criticism, I hope you handle it well.

Best of luck, and please take this suggestion. Start a website, and make a post with a simple link to your column. That would be much easier.

BED-STYPUNDIT
24 Apr 2006, 10:05 PM
unlike most everyone else, im gonna thank you for the post. i enjoyed reading it alot. good to see a summed up and compiled look at all the guys who could have been for this cycle. im not gonna rip ya man, i appreciate the offering.



forza inter

Thank much yourself, you can never say enough thank you's.