Who should be the starting goalkeeper for the USMNT?

[sarabella]

Who should be the starting keeper?

[Pints]

hmmm....I thought Friedel had backed down from playing in the USMNT?

[SABuffalo786]

Keller's the man for qualifying.

[lillefty7]

hmmm....I thought Friedel had backed down from playing in the USMNT?


I think it is that he doesnt like missing club commitments for playin for the US national team

[fermi]

there all quailty. i suppose you'd have to go with there form for there club team. i would hate to see howard and keller be overlooked because they aren't starting. but it looks like keller is doing good for mochengladbach (spelling).i think that were lucky to have 3 top notch keepers

[ZiggyGalaxy]

Nobody can make Friedel play...if he wants to focus on his struggling team and ignore the promise of the Nats, let it be so. Also, Kasey apparantly looked superb in the Monchengladbach game...so it's ok... :D

[tomas_brolin]

personally i think keller should get the nod, he has started the past few wc qualfiers. he is finally getting more playing time so he will only get better i think. howard will have to earn his starting spot again, but carroll is doing crappingly so howard could get it back unless ricardo sneaks in and get the starting job. friedel has been doing solid from what i hear. the only reason he looks so bad is that the defense for blackburn is so horrid.

i would like to see hahnemann recalled again though.

[jmeissen0]

i'd rather not call friedel or keller in for this one (relegation struggle and new team)

timmy might be the best bet


but i would prefer friedel in goal any time, every time


no tale of friedel does him justice... he is the alpha and the omega

[galperin]

KK is the man.

However, b/c of KK's recent move, Timmy should get the nod for the T&T game.

[spot]

Cannon

[hiddink_magic]

I voted for Tim Howard. But mind you I am an Aussie, so I could be very wrong about what I am posting.

[Jasonisimo]

Of course, Kasey Keller is the most experience goalkeeper the USA has, and he wants to continue playing for the nats. He is the natural choice.

Should he not ask Keller for his services, Arena should call in Marcus Hanneman(sp?) or give one of the MLS guys a chance, Cannon or Hartman. As for Howard starting in Qs, I think Bruce should stick to his guns about players needing to start for their clubs first. If he wants to establish conditions like that, he should enforce them where appropriate.

[Czar Pazzo]

My pick is Keller:

http://www.barcelonadc.com/sounds/kasey_keller.mp3

[galaxyfan03]

I've always been a fan of Keller & he's my choice. However, Brad is having a solid season at Blackburn after a poor start & IF he was interested in re-joining the USMNT, he would be VERY hard to put on the bench.

MY feeling is that Big Brad feels that he had the World Cup of his life in Korea/Japan & has NOTHING left to prove on the international stage. I just don't think he wants to play for the USMNT anymore, unfortunately. Hopefully, I'm wrong but I don't think we'll lose a lot at the position because of our depth at GK.

Germany 2006 will be Kasey Keller's "moment to shine" IMHO and I think he'll be up to the task!!

[SoccerPrime]

Just reading up on Keller, Howard and Friedal recently, seems that Kasey Keller is the hungriest and most pro-active about playing and doing well. Thats what I want in our starting NT GK.

[Tmagic77]

i'd rather not call friedel or keller in for this one (relegation struggle and new team)

timmy might be the best bet


but i would prefer friedel in goal any time, every time


no tale of friedel does him justice... he is the alpha and the omega

Why don't you just ask Segroves?

[schnoopa]

Since Freidel is preoccupied with the EPL, and since Blackburn advanced today. Why not Raimundo, or Johnny Walker or somebody from the MLS. Get some new blood, or the U21 keeper. Freidel & Keller have a lock, but Howard looked shakey and would need the exposure as would some new talent. Walker looked pretty good and he's got the cola cola (spelling sucks) experence.

[wrightcor]

Not Howard at this time that is for sure. The keeper should be starting for his club. How about MLS keepers (Walker or Cannon) with a possible third or fourth MLS keeper.

[ScissorsKick]

I would go with Howard. Just because he doesn't start GK at ManUtd doesn't mean he isn't the best for the job. Howard has potential for greatness and has the skill and speed for the national level. Freidal and Keller are great GKs in the own right, but they do seem like they have lost a step. Age will do that to even the best. Just ask Michael Jordan. I really like both Freidal's and Howard's attitudes on the field. However, I haven't been impressed with some of Keller's psycho antics I've seen in the past when things aren't going well. He always seems well composed, and then he seems to snaps anytime he has to do his job and make a save. There is a difference between inspiring your defense to step up and just being a whiner. I may be being harsh, but Keller seems to do a lot of unnecessary whining on the field. I would also like to see some MLS keepers get a shot at the job, but Howard should have the start in my book. Maybe Howard should go back to MLS for a permanent start job just so he meets the "criteria" of starting for his club team.

[ScissorsKick]

I would go with Howard. Just because he doesn't start GK at ManUtd doesn't mean he isn't the best for the job. Howard has potential for greatness and has the skill and speed for the national level. Freidel and Keller are great GKs in the own right, but they do seem like they have lost a step. Age will do that to even the best. Just ask Michael Jordan. I really like both Freidel's and Howard's attitudes on the field. However, I haven't been impressed with some of Keller's psycho antics I've seen in the past when things aren't going well. He always seems well composed, and then he seems to snaps anytime he has to do his job and make a save. There is a difference between inspiring your defense to step up and just being a whiner. I may be being harsh, but Keller seems to do a lot of unnecessary whining on the field. I would also like to see some MLS keepers get a shot at the job, but Howard should have the start in my book. Maybe Howard should go back to MLS for a permanent start job just so he meets the "criteria" of starting for his club team.