Who is the best goalkeeper right now?

[Teso Dos Bichos]

what are you talking about??? best goalkeeper in 1999, 2000, 2001 and 2002. THE BEST GOALKEEPER EVER.

Schmeichel was better.

If you look at the voting for the Ballon d'Or and identify who the best ranked keeper was each year, in the entire history of the award the only keeper ahead of Schmeichel was Lev Yashin.

[Psychosis hsv]

right now its scott carson

[Yankshire Pud]

Phil Neville.

[thebigman]

whats all this ochoa talk? he plays in mexico ffs

Schmeichel was a beast, cech and buffon are the best right now...almunia is probably just outside the top 50

:(

[t_zelenka]

Petr Cech

[L.G.S]

1. Cech
2. Buffon
3. Zoff

[KumarsS]

Based on form this season:

1. Petr Cech (Chelsea)
2. Iker Casillas (Real Madrid)
3. Sebastien Frey (Fiorentina)
4. Gianluigi Buffon (Juventus)
5. Robert Enke (Hannover 96)
6. Carlos Kameni (Espanyol)
7. Manuel Neuer (Schalke 04)
8. Julio Cesar (Inter Milan)
9. Scott Carson (Aston Villa)
10. Jose Reina (Liverpool)

[Glavisted Big Soccer]

Right now:

01. Gianluigi Buffon (Italy & Juventus)
02. Petr Cech (Czech Republic & Chelsea)
03. Íker Casillas (Spain & Real Madrid)
04. Guillermo Ochoa (Mexico & America)
05. Julio César (Brazil & Inter Milan)
06. Artur Boruc (Poland & Celtic)
07. Robert Enke (Germany & Hannover 96)
08. Sebastien Frey (France & Fiorentina)
09. Carlos Kameni (Cameroon & Espanyol)
10. Edwin van der Sar (Holland & Manchester United)

[L.G.S]

Based on form this season:

1. Petr Cech (Chelsea)
2. Iker Casillas (Real Madrid)
3. Sebastien Frey (Fiorentina)
4. Gianluigi Buffon (Juventus)
5. Robert Enke (Hannover 96)
6. Carlos Kameni (Espanyol)
7. Manuel Neuer (Schalke 04)
8. Julio Cesar (Inter Milan)
9. Scott Carson (Aston Villa)
10. Jose Reina (Liverpool)

If it's from this season, Casper Schmeichel needs to be on that list.

[Teso Dos Bichos]

06. Artur Boruc (Poland & Celtic)

Makes far too many mistakes, even if you only want to look at this season, and is simply an overrated shot stopper.

[NumberSoul]

Makes far too many mistakes, even if you only want to look at this season, and is simply an overrated shot stopper.

Well when it comes to the big games I don't think he ever made a mistake.

[Hargo]

Van Der Sar - he's been in great form, his distribution has helped a few Manchester United goals too.

[Glavisted Big Soccer]

Makes far too many mistakes, even if you only want to look at this season, and is simply an overrated shot stopper.
Isn't correct, he has a good season and I think his position in my ranking is deserved.

[Tony Dellbird]

Tim Howard?

[Smoga]

Makes far too many mistakes, even if you only want to look at this season, and is simply an overrated shot stopper.
Dude, were you one of the thugs that Boruc beat up in that park while defending some lady? It certainly seems like you have some kind of a personal vendetta against him...

[Yid_Army99]

Boruc then Casillas

[marrypirlo]

For this season I would have to say Frey(up until sunday) but Buffon is just amazing, he just can't seem to do anything wrong, ever and he has been playing really well this year again!

[Teso Dos Bichos]

Isn't correct, he has a good season and I think his position in my ranking is deserved.

You clearly have not seen his regular performances and are guilty of basing your opinion on a few games and highlight reels. This season alone he has made countless mistakes, several costing Celtic crucial points against their main rivals.

Dude, were you one of the thugs that Boruc beat up in that park while defending some lady? It certainly seems like you have some kind of a personal vendetta against him...

The only vendetta I have is against the ignorant in our midst who are proclaiming him to be something he is not.

[Glavisted Big Soccer]

You clearly have not seen his regular performances and are guilty of basing your opinion on a few games and highlight reels. This season alone he has made countless mistakes, several costing Celtic crucial points against their main rivals.
Actually that isn't true. Besides Champions League's games with the SAT Football I could watched him against of Dundee United and Motherwell in September, Falkirk and Aberdeen at the beginning of the season and at least his last four games with Poland in the Euro Qualifying against of Russia, Portugal and Finland.

So, more or less 10 completes matches since August, that could be consider clearly more than only highlights, couldn't :D?

I think Boruc is far of be guilty of a lot mistakes in the season, not only for Celtic, too for Poland, he has had a good season and again, I think he deserves his position in my ranking.

[Teso Dos Bichos]

Let's see what Boruc has to say:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/teams/c/celtic/7009570.stm


That is but one game. He's made numerous other mistakes this season. He is a good keeper but like all shot stoppers he has failings in the rest of his game and these have resulted in more mistakes than usual this season. He's not as good as people here seem to think.