Penalty kick "continuation"

[Wahoos1]

Need some help. I remember some time ago lots of discussion of a foul beginning outside the PA and continuing into the PA resulting in a PK. Google has "not" been my friend on this, nor ussoccer.com, asktheref etc.

Any help with links, videos etc?

[AlsoRan]

FIFA Questions and Answers on the Laws of the Game, 2006. Law 12 Question 31.
31. A defender starts holding an attacker outside the penalty area but finishes
inside the penalty area. What action should the referee take?
He would award a penalty kick.

[AlsoRan]

2009 LOTG INTERPRETATION OF THE LAWS OF THE GAME AND GUIDELINES FOR REFEREES Page 109

If a defender starts holding an attacker outside the penalty area and
continues holding him inside the penalty area, the referee must award
a penalty kick.

[Jasonma]

Need some help. I remember some time ago lots of discussion of a foul beginning outside the PA and continuing into the PA resulting in a PK. Google has "not" been my friend on this, nor ussoccer.com, asktheref etc.

Any help with links, videos etc?

The specific instance you may be referring to (Which was not a hold but a possible continued shove IIRC) was Colorado's Facundo Erpen vs. Chivas USA's Merlin in 2007.

[AlsoRan]

From 2008 Week in Review - with video
http://www.thereflink.com/USSOCCER/index.html#_Toc216853293

[Wahoos1]

Thanks.