Discussion in 'Bayern Munich' started by ForeverRed, Oct 30, 2012.
I'll pass on both.
would you guys prefer having our german talent spread out across 5-6 teams like it is now. Or condensed to 2 super teams like spain does?
Bayern and Dortmund. Barcelona and Real Madrid.
Dortmund can have ozil and khedira with schurrle in there aswell
6-7 teams. It makes for a much better league.
would you prefer ozil and khedira back in germany? Are they being there getting the german brand fruther globally?
Nah, I like them right were they are. I think they are nurtured by a coach like Mourinho that values them.
Don't care as long as they're far away from Bayern.
Plus I guess playing consistently at the highest level at one of the biggest clubs in the world won't hurt either
More German players should move to the PL or La Liga IMO, especially the latter, they'll improve big time there.
It doesn't and the "biggest" talents are already condensed to two "super teams" in Germany too.
Dortmund: Hummels, S. Bender, Gündogan, Götze, Reus, Schmelzer, Leitner
Bayern: Neuer, Badstuber, Boateng, Lahm, Schweinsteiger, Kroos, Müller, Gomez
You could argue that there is a third team with Schalke (Höwedes, Draxler, Holtby, maybe Neustädter) but their german players have hardly played any role in the NT so far and aren't as numerous.
So is there even much of a difference to Spain and Real/Barca?
You have Khedira and Özil outside of Bayern/BVB but there are also David Silva, Cazorla, Torres, Soldado, Martinez etc.
I can also tell you why it's better for the league this way: Look at the last 2,5 years.
The quality has increased overall because Bayern and Dortmund raise the bar for each other but also for the rest of the league.
They can just as easily improve in the BL. Such a move makes sense if we talk about players who might want to play at a bigger club but can't find a place at Bayern or Dortmund but besides that I don't see the need.
Overall it would be a better sign if the BL can keep its good players.
He wins for the right answer.
I am saying I would prefer the wealth of talent to not be condensed in just 2 clubs but throughout the whole league.
I meant the both of them. Schurrle seems like a great prospect despite his shortcomings as a player.
If they can go to the elite clubs in Spain then I say its worth it because they'll improve a lot. If its to bottom sides then obviously not.
The only Spanish clubs which can attract German top-class talents are Barca and Real.You won`t see players like Schurrle or Reus joining clubs like Valencia or Atletico in the future.
But that won't happen anyways if we produce a lot of talent just like Barca and Real can't sign every good spanish player. In the end the number of starting places is kinda a natural limit.
The other teams don't need to worry about Bayern and Dortmund, they need to worry about foreign clubs coming in and trying to buy every decent players and we already see signs of that.
"elite clubs" = Real/Barca so that concerns just a handfulf of german players.
I also don't mind if our players go to ManUtd, Arsenal or even Chelsea and ManCity but that's about it and only if the player is "ready" for it.
I just don't want that we become a 2nd France exporting all our best players throughout Europe.
I definetly would prefer our best players to be spread amongst the top teams here first then abroad.
Especially Barca and Madrid.,
Apparently Boenisch (former Werder Bremen) had no club and now signed a contract with Bayer Leverkusen til the end of the season.
I thought he still played at Bremen. :lol:
I was stating what I would like to see, not what I think is happening or what is going to happen.
Not all, we produce so many players that we can afford to have a couple play abroad. It would improve them and the NT in the process.
If I were Bayer 04, I'd tell both clubs to take that 20 million and shove it shiny
Any intending German star player should stay in the BL or go to sensible clubs like Barca, Real, Man Utd, Not the direction lacking Arsenal nor at Citeh under Mancini
Schuerrle's ceiling is much higher.
He just needs the right place to develop.
he's worth it by a long shot. I personally thought he should've left this season, man united would have been perfect for him.
Separate names with a comma.