Results 12 points for 1st, 11 for 2nd etc. I've not included a vote for Holy__Joe as it has no impact on the overall standings. Ties are decided by counting most number of 1st place votes, then most 2nd place if required and so on. 1st cr7torossi & JamesA - 101 points 2nd Stud83 - 101 points 3rd nicephoras & schwuppe - 93 points 4th Twenty26Six - 89 points 5th thebigman & PDG1978 - 87 points 6th Salama - 75 points 7th soccernutter - 75 points 8th benni... & SyedZada - 74 points 9th Peru FC - 70 points 10th Excape Goat - 70 points 11th AudereEstFacere - 46 points 12th El-CapitanoR7 - 32 points 13th Holy__Joe -23 points 1st place votes cr7torossi & JamesA - 3 Twenty26Six - 2 Salama- 2 Peru FC- 2 nicephoras & schwuppe - 1 soccernutter - 1 thebigman & PDG1978 - 1 Last place votes Holy__Joe - 7 AudereEstFacere - 2 El-CapitanoR7 - 2 Peru FC- 1 Highest placed ranking cr7torossi & JamesA - 1 Stud83 - 2 nicephoras & schwuppe - 1 Twenty26Six - 1 thebigman & PDG1978 - 1 Salama - 1 soccernutter - 1 benni... & SyedZada - 3 Peru FC - 1 Excape Goat - 2 AudereEstFacere - 2 El-CapitanoR7 - 7 Holy__Joe - 9 Lowest placed ranking cr7torossi & JamesA - 8 Stud83 - 7 nicephoras & schwuppe - 9 Twenty26Six - 10 thebigman & PDG1978 - 11 Salama - 11 soccernutter - 11 benni... & SyedZada - 9 Peru FC - 12 Excape Goat - 11 AudereEstFacere - 12 El-CapitanoR7 - 12 Holy__Joe - 12 Number of different positions in rankings cr7torossi & JamesA - 7 Stud83 - 4 nicephoras & schwuppe - 7 Twenty26Six - 7 thebigman & PDG1978 - 7 Salama - 9 soccernutter - 9 benni... & SyedZada - 6 Peru FC - 6 Excape Goat - 7 AudereEstFacere - 8 El-CapitanoR7 - 6 Holy__Joe -3 Most common rankings Holy__Joe - 7 times 12th Stud83 - 6 times 3rd thebigman & PDG1978 - 4 times 4th Holy__Joe - 4 times 10th No others over 3 times. Number of different teams per ranking 1st - 7 2nd - 9 3rd - 5 4th - 7 5th - 6 6th - 9 7th - 8 8th - 9 9th - 8 10th - 7 11th - 7 12th - 4
Congratulations ot cr7torossi and JamesA. Pretty close in the end for the top spot. Thanks to everyone for taking part - if there is the demand there'll be another All Time Sheep Draft in the new year and another Current Player Sheep Draft later on.
Congrats to cr7torossi and JamesA, I was one of the people who voted you as #1. If I didn't put your first, I would've won the whole thing without having a single first place vote Here's my final list: 1. cr7torossi 2. thebigman 3. nicephoras 4. Twenty26Six 5. benni 6. Salama 7. Perú FC 8. Excape Goat 9. AudereEstFacere 10. soccernutter 11. El-CapitanoR7 12. Holy_Joe
The joint vote from me and thebigman was as follows (with my ranking in brackets): 1) Twenty26Six (2) 2) Soccernutter (6) 3) Stud83 (4) 4) Syed&benni (3) 5) Nicephoras&schwuppe (7) 6) cr7torossi&JamesA (5) 7) Peru FC (1) 8) Salama (11) 9) Excape Goat (8) 10) Holy Joe (10) 11) El-Capitano R9 (9) 12) AudereEstFacere (12) thebigman marked the teams out of 10 and PM'd me, and then I allocated points according to both our orders giving the team thebigman placed higher the higher joint placing if there was a tie. I'll let him go into more detail if he likes but his marks out of 10 ranged from 7.75 to his top ranked team (Twenty26Six - closely followed by others around that mark) down to 6 out of 10. I definately had it very close at the top and bottom, and maybe even moreso in the middle (the order between them - there were a few that I felt would be in the middle somewhere). We both gave Holy Joe the benefit of the doubt and judged his team on lanman's chosen XI and a positive interpretation of how it would work I think - thebigman gave him 7/10 which he also gave to Excape Goat while I would have had him about tied with El-Capitano's team so we did count his team as below those in our seperate rankings before making the joint one. Congratulations cr7torossi and JamesA, and unlucky Stud83 that's about as close as you can get to winning it without doing! Thought there may be quite a few different choices for the top teams, as it turned out indeed- all the teams are within the same ballpark I think.
Congrats to cr7torossi & JamesA, and tough luck to Stud - it like losing the championship on goals scored. Had fun, even though I could not put much time into it as I wanted. Looking forward to the all time draft if one happens.
"Congrats guys. My team is about where I expected give or take. Before the last round, I was more confident. Rossi's core was just too good. ? Anyone want to give thoughts on my team? El Capitano. You had a good system, just some average players.
I was hoping to get a first place vote and a spot in the top 4, so I am happy how it played out. Congrats to rossi/james for winning. I had them first in my rankings. Thanks to PDG/Big for making me their #1. If I had to guess who gave me my other #1, I would say Peru. He always seems to grade me well. This draft was very fun, and the degree of difficulty was higher than usual - which made it even more interesting.
Congrats to cr7torossi & JamesA. I knew that I did not have a chance to win it and I also knew that I was not the bottom team. So I am satisfied with my performance.
I rated your team higher than the final order. You were my 4th. I might have overrated your team because you consisted of a few of my favorite players, namely, Valero, Ozil, Di Maria and Reus. The forward definitely worked. In a previous post, I mentioned about Isco on your team. I realized my mistake during the final judging.
At this point, you are one of the ones I can actually explain why... I like what you did with your tactics. It was fairly consistent in formation with a rotation of players. As I did with all teams, I thought about how that would do compared to my team, and I could see your team getting through my center 3 (De Jong, Vertonghen, Ramos). Thusly, I put you at 3rd.
Things I liked about your team: -Solid midfield -Good formation and write-up, covered everything very well. Didn't like: -Koscielny with De Gea behind is not a very consistent -You dropped Isco from the team, drafted Reus at the end and put Isla in the center of the midfield? Didn't make sense with your formation. You needed a CM/DM there with the last pick to play next to Valero. Isla then would've gone to the right, Jallet dropped and Ozil/Di Maria/Isco is very solid up front.
Thanks guys for your feed back. I dont know if you can tell by the blocks and picks in the last round, but you, stud and Rossi both thwarted me in my attempts to get a midfielder. Vidal was just a throw away pick/block, but I wanted Schweini.... If I couldnt get a holding midfielder to my expectation, I was going to go all out attack like last draft. In the end, I was probably too cautious in the early rounds.
I honestly thought Peru was going to be # 1. I really thought his team " made sense" more than any other team, including mine. I must admit that I am slightly disappointed by the rating I got in the draft, I really thought my team was very difficult to play against, and had a good balance, but at the end it's simply a matter of opinion. Congrats to the winners, I had a lot of fun.
just want to say thanks to whom ever voted me as the top. I was hoping for a top 4 and a trip to the CL, but I just barely made the Other Cup.
Also, Thanks Lanman. If you're not busy, can you give your opinion on the draft and the teams in general?
Yes, I meant to ask for this as well. Great overlord and benevolent dictator of Sheep Draft 3.5, humbly provide us with your wise words.