I have seen him mis-control the ball. He's NOT a great passer out of the back. I have also seen him botch-up a couple of clearances. I have also seen some games where he was out in out bad. At the same time I have also seen him make some VERY strong meaningful tackles that potentially saved Gaudette from point blank shots. I have seen him read and break-up plays too. I have seen plenty of games where he hasn't been BAD. He's an average to slightly below average MLS Defender, but a far cry from some sort of complete disaster. You are like a woman scorned whom just can't see passed his first 5 games or so where he WAS a disaster area.