Who dafuq closes a thread in the middle of a discussion? I imagine once we transfer Joselu the only reason he comes back is so we can sell him on for a profit Negredo style, IMO he's never had the first team look about him. And a young FB like Carvajal needs to be getting consistent minutes of football to really develop, you thinking he would get them here is a notion that has no basis in reality. He would be Arbeloa's backup, if that, Mou still would probably use Lass or Ramos in a pinch. Carvajal is a lot like Marcelo, same strengths and weaknesses, albeit it Dani is probably a better defender than Marcelo at the same age. I don't really see Mou (or this forum) suffering his growing pains lightly so why not let him broaden his horizons as a player and an individual somewhere else for awhile? He gets experience and a first team contract and we can keep an eye on him for the future, all parties have the same ultimate goal in mind and that is for the player to return. I don't see the downside to this arrangement.