Let's end the Debate (at least for this year): MLS vs Mexican clubs

1) Is this based on any tangible evidence or just observations? just curious.

2) Was the purpose of this thread to show the MLS' minimum imporvement? Do you have examples of that?

What logic is behind this threads premise and "Statistical Analysis?"

Typically you don't see much argument from Mexican fans when posters have good statistical evidence to backup their claims... see that NoSix and other posters who come up with coeficients for CONCACAF rarely get blasted.

 

no. it's not. just because you think a few morons and a sock or two represent the standard US fans beliefs about the game doesn't make it so.

There are a lot more examples of reasonable and rational US posters on the Concacaf boards than Mexican posters. When some idiot American stumbles in here spouting off crap, they're quickly shown the door (by US and non-US posters alike) and rarely return. Non-US trolls are given the longest possible leash imaginable.

Let's put it this way: if It's called FOOTBALL or getthomas were US fans, they'd both be permanently red carded by now. God knows why they haven't been already anyway...

 

@tomwilhelm: WTH. Why are u saying I should be redcarded?

And you're dead wrong on the percentage of US fans who are reasonable. There are far more ignorant US fan posters than ignorant Mexico fans. We could go back and forth on this all day. The best way to somewhat settle this is to start a poll.

 

I am so dumbfounded that I can't even find the right response...

 

This is moronic if you take in account the Superliga, to make it worth anything you can only take the CCL, home and away. O wait.... i forgot MLS has never beaten mexican clubs in Mexico, so it dosnt really matter any club winning aways proves whos better.

Like you said, in the future things could change, as of right now this ''debate'' is moronic. (you cant call a debate something witch is already decided and proven).

Keep dreaming little dude, youll see by the end of the CLL what league is the daddy of the area.

I still dont get where do they get the ideas of things like MLS >= FMF.

 

I guess you're part of that 10% aren't you?

 

PWNED

just like when William Wallace slits the guys throat

 

you have to understand that he wants to prove that mls and mfl are right now at the same level no matter what,and if they win the prestigious superliga thats gonna prove it, and because RECENT history prove him wrong he doesnt count it,he even ignores the fact that mfl won the last three tourneys in a row,even if MFL wins the next ccl hes gonna be here doing the same, and even when he says that he is neutral, he always favors the usa in many posts and at the end he always says im neutral,what a spazzo.thats why he always says right now, with his way of thinking usa is right now the second best team in the world behind brazil,due to the confed cup,history doesnt count to him not even recent history. hey gringolimon admit you are an american fan its not a crime,just come out of the closet

 

Communication is difficult for retarded people, so I am not surprised in the least bit.


I think we should stick tomwilhelm and lime in a closet together. They'll find love in no time.

 

Will you stop with your pathetic obsession to prove something to us?

We've given you too many facts of why RIGHT NOW the FMF is the better league (don't even bring up the past, for your sake). Results speak for themselves. Right now we have Atlanta going to the club world cup because they beat another Mexican team to get their. 3 Mexican teams in the semis speaks volumes. Give it a rest.

World leagues don't revolve around SuperLiga, a preseason mini cup from Mexico's eyes and rightly so.

 

You feel sorry for a woman whose athletic trophy case puts mine and yours to shame? Who grew up on more land than you and I did combined?

Anyway, it's obvious you're cracking on the inside. Just close these threads and get some sleep. You've embarrassed yourself enough.

 

I won't start considering MLS the equal as FMF until MLS teams start winning away games in Mexico, at least occasionally. It's not likely to happen anytime soon either given MLS salary constraints compared to FMF.

Superliga is pretty meaningless but I expect it to continue for as long as it is a decent moneymaker for FMF, MLS, and the TV folks.

 

3-2-3 does not equal 50% winning percentage. Wins/games played X 100.

As for the knockout portion. Are you counting games that end in PKs as ties?